The intraparty hostility exploded just days before the state’s April 1 budget deadline, with lobbyists and special interests racing to ensure that their priorities are included in a spending plan expected to exceed $170 billion.
The flare-up began Wednesday evening, when the three lawmakers held an impromptu news conference in a Capitol hallway. Sens. Alessandra Biaggi and Jessica Ramos, who took office last year by defeating powerful Democratic incumbents, and Yuh-Line Niou, a second-term assemblywoman, said they were outraged by a New York Times article that detailed a mid-March fundraiser by Cuomo where entry for a couple cost $25,000.
The article, published hours before the women’s news conference, described how lobbyists and business executives flocked to the event at the St. Regis Hotel in Manhattan for face time with him as well as with his budget director, Robert Mujica, who oversees the budget negotiation process.
During the news conference, Biaggi called the fundraiser, which was not advertised on the governor’s public schedule, “exactly what we have come to Albany to change.”
“Show me another example at another state where there is a governor, during the budget process, raising $25,000 a ticket,” she said.
The women said the article proved the need for a public financing system for campaigns, a system that Cuomo has also championed.
But Biaggi said that for Cuomo to make that call while hosting such events, she added, was “hypocritical.”
“It is impossible to say a $25,000 ticket is not influencing the decisions,” she said.
Cuomo’s office quickly fired back. Richard Azzopardi, a senior adviser to the governor, walked through the Capitol’s press office, excoriating the three legislators as “(expletive) idiots.” When a reporter asked if that comment was on the record, Azzopardi did not hesitate. “Yeah.”
He pointed out that Ramos herself had hosted a fundraiser in Albany on March 6, for between $250 and $5,000 per person. Melissa DeRosa, the governor’s top aide, used Twitter on Thursday to accuse Biaggi of lying when she said she had not held any fundraisers during the budget season, sharing an invitation to a fundraiser for Biaggi on Feb. 28. Admission ranged from $250 to $2,500.
“Hypocrisy is one thing,” DeRosa wrote. “Willful lying is another.”
During the news conference, Ramos acknowledged holding her own fundraiser, but said she had returned contributions from people whose political beliefs did not align with hers. She also said that she would support a ban on fundraisers during the budget season, but that she would operate under the current rules until then.
Cuomo defended his fundraising methods similarly, saying he would “live within the campaign finance system” until it was changed.
Biaggi replied to DeRosa on Twitter by noting that she had not held a fundraiser in the capital — the February fundraiser was in New York City — and that she would “never have a fundraiser during budget.”
Budget season is not clearly defined in Albany: Cuomo delivered his budget address on Jan. 15, and the budget is due April 1. In between, both legislative chambers release budget proposals and negotiate furiously for their own ends.
The Senate Democrats’ campaign committee has actively raised money over the past few months, too: On Wednesday, just before the lawmakers’ news conference, the committee sent supporters an invitation to a “spring reception” on April 18. The reception would be hosted by the Senate majority leader, Andrea Stewart-Cousins, and the requested donations ranged from $1,000 to $25,000.
A “labor breakfast” on Mar. 5 had asked for the same amounts, as did a “winter reception” on Jan. 22.
The month before the budget deadline is by far the busiest period of the legislative session for fundraisers: In March 2018, lawmakers held at least 77 such events, more than double the number held in the next busiest month, according to data compiled by the New York Public Interest Research Group, a government reform organization.
And most legislators are in no hurry to change that tradition.
At least 29 other states prohibit lobbyists or their clients from making campaign contributions during the legislative session, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. Yet in New York, a bill to ban fundraisers during the session has foundered for nearly two decades.
Carl E. Heastie, the Assembly speaker, said he did not believe Cuomo’s fundraiser, or any budget-time fundraiser, was inappropriate. He has also expressed skepticism about the feasibility of public financing.
“We should really just be trying to work together at this point, not point fingers, not try to say that everything in this business is corruptive and corrupted,” he said.
Legislative leaders reinforced that message privately. On Thursday, Senate leaders asked their members during a meeting to be strategic about their tactics before the budget; the day before, less than 15 minutes after the women’s news conference had concluded, Heastie pulled Niou aside.
Heastie on Thursday told reporters that his conversation with Niou “went fine,” as he stressed the importance for lawmakers to remain collegial with one another.
“I think that also brings a negative view to our constituents, if we’re always saying that every single thing that motivates us is being done because of some corruptive motive,” Heastie added. “I think it’s a problem.”
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.